If you own a home and want to raise a significant sum, two routes typically emerge: a remortgage, which replaces your existing deal and releases equity in a single new mortgage, or a secured loan (also called a second charge mortgage), which borrows alongside your existing mortgage without disturbing it. Both use your property as security. Both can unlock the same equity. The decision between them is not about which product is inherently superior: it is about which one is cheaper and more practical given your specific mortgage situation.
The single most important factor in that decision is usually the early repayment charge on the existing mortgage. A large ERC can make breaking a current deal very expensive, and in those cases a secured loan will often be significantly cheaper overall even though its interest rate is higher. But the calculation is more nuanced than simply checking whether an ERC exists: it also depends on the rate you would give up on the existing balance, the amount being borrowed, and the terms of each loan. This guide walks through both options, provides a worked example, and includes two calculators: a quick cost comparison on the new borrowing alone, and a full comparator that models your whole mortgage position under each route.
At a Glance
-
The ERC on the existing mortgage is usually the single biggest factor, but rate protection matters just as much. Both can make a secured loan cheaper even though its interest rate is higher.
A remortgage ends the existing deal. If the mortgage is within a fixed period, the ERC (typically 1% to 5% of the outstanding balance) is added to the cost of the remortgage route. A secured loan avoids the ERC entirely because the existing mortgage is left in place. But even where no ERC applies, a secured loan can still be the better route if the existing mortgage rate is well below current market rates: remortgaging would replace that rate on the entire balance, while the secured loan only pays the higher rate on the new borrowing. The more owed on the existing mortgage, the more valuable rate protection becomes.
› The decision framework · Can I protect my rate even with no ERC?
-
A shorter secured loan term at a higher rate can produce a lower total cost than a longer remortgage at a lower rate. Monthly payment is not the right comparison metric; total cost is.
The worked example in this guide shows a scenario where a secured loan at 9% over 10 years costs approximately £486 less in total than a remortgage at 5.2% over 15 years once the ERC is included. The remortgage has the lower monthly payment, but the longer term means interest accrues for five additional years. Comparing monthly payments alone would make the remortgage look decisively better; comparing total costs shows the secured loan is cheaper once the ERC is accounted for. This is a common pattern, not an edge case.
-
The break-even ERC, the exact charge at which both routes cost the same, varies significantly with the inputs. Two calculators on this page make the comparison explicit for your own figures.
The break-even depends on the amount being borrowed, the rate on each route, and the term of each loan. In the worked example it is approximately £3,114: any ERC above that figure makes the secured loan cheaper overall. The quick calculator isolates that break-even for the new borrowing alone. The full comparator goes further and models your existing mortgage balance, rate and remaining term under each route, which is where the cost of giving up a low existing rate, or of stretching the existing debt over a longer term, becomes visible in pounds.
The Core Difference
The simplest way to understand the difference is to think about what happens to your existing mortgage. A remortgage ends the current deal. The existing mortgage lender is repaid in full (or you transfer to a new product with them), and if the new mortgage is larger than the existing balance, the difference is released as cash. You end up with one mortgage, one monthly payment, one lender. A secured loan, by contrast, leaves the existing mortgage completely untouched. A second, separate loan is arranged against the property, secured by a second legal charge registered at HM Land Registry behind the first. You end up with two separate commitments running in parallel.
Remortgage to release equity
One mortgage replaces another
The existing mortgage is closed and a new, larger one is opened. The difference between the old balance and the new mortgage amount is paid to you. Only one lender holds a charge on the property. This is the standard approach at the end of a fixed-rate deal when switching to a new product or lender.
Secured loan (second charge mortgage)
A second loan sits alongside the first
The existing mortgage continues on its current terms. A separate second charge loan is added. Two lenders each hold a legal charge on the property. The second charge lender ranks behind the first in repayment priority. Two monthly payments run concurrently.
Both products are regulated by the FCA. Since March 2016, second charge mortgages have been regulated under the same Mortgage Credit Directive rules as first charge mortgages, so both routes come with the same consumer protections: affordability assessment, a standardised European Standardised Information Sheet (ESIS) before commitment, and regulated conduct if difficulties arise. The second charge mortgage guide explains the regulatory framework and legal charge structure in detail.
How Remortgaging to Release Equity Works
Remortgaging to release equity means borrowing more than the current outstanding mortgage balance when you switch deals. A homeowner with £150,000 remaining on a mortgage who needs £30,000 would remortgage to £180,000, with the lender paying out the existing £150,000 balance and releasing the remaining £30,000 as cash. The new mortgage is at the new lender's current rate, over a new term.
The economics of this route are most favourable when timed correctly. Most fixed-rate mortgage deals carry early repayment charges during the fixed period, typically 1% to 5% of the outstanding balance. Breaking a £150,000 mortgage with a 2% ERC costs £3,000. Once the fixed period ends, ERCs usually disappear and the borrower can remortgage freely. Borrowing more from your existing lender is also possible as a further advance (an additional loan on top of your current deal, without switching lender), though further advance rates are not always competitive and the existing lender applies its own affordability limits. The second charge vs further advance comparator compares those two options directly. The first charge rate on a remortgage is almost always lower than the rate on a second charge secured loan for the same property and borrower profile, because the first charge lender faces lower risk.
How a Secured Loan Works to Raise Capital
A secured loan borrows against the equity in a property without touching the existing mortgage. The amount available is determined by the combined loan-to-value (the sum of the existing mortgage plus the new loan as a percentage of the property value): most second charge lenders lend up to around 85% combined LTV, with some specialist lenders going higher at a premium rate. The loan is assessed on affordability, credit history, property condition, and the existing mortgage terms, and a second charge is registered at HM Land Registry when the loan completes.
Because the second charge lender ranks behind the first mortgage lender in repayment priority, they carry higher risk. If the property were sold following a default, the first charge lender is repaid first; the second charge lender receives whatever remains. This elevated risk is why second charge mortgage rates are higher than first charge mortgage rates, typically several percentage points above what a remortgage of the same property would achieve. This rate premium is the main cost of protecting an existing mortgage deal. The secured loan eligibility guide covers what lenders assess in detail, and the APR guide explains how secured loan rates are structured.
The Decision Framework: Six Triggers
In practice, the decision usually comes down to a small number of concrete factors. The following triggers are a practical starting point: if most point in one direction, that route is worth exploring first.
| Situation | Points towards | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Existing fixed deal has 1+ years to run with a substantial ERC | Secured loan | ERC adds thousands to the remortgage cost; secured loan avoids it entirely |
| Current mortgage rate is significantly below what is available today | Secured loan | Remortgaging locks in a higher rate on the entire balance; secured loan protects the existing rate |
| Income, employment or credit has changed since the original mortgage | Secured loan | A remortgage involves a full reassessment by the new lender; second charge underwriting is typically more flexible on changed circumstances |
| Existing deal is ending in the next 3 months or already on SVR | Remortgage | No (or minimal) ERC; can consolidate into one competitive deal |
| Large amount to borrow relative to existing balance | Remortgage | The rate differential matters more at larger amounts; first charge rate advantage compounds over a long term |
| Speed is important (funds needed within 4 to 6 weeks) | Secured loan | Second charge mortgages typically complete in 4 to 8 weeks; a remortgage with a new lender usually takes 2 to 4 weeks longer |
No single trigger is definitive on its own. A large ERC and a favourable existing rate both push strongly toward the secured loan route, but if the amount being borrowed is very large and the existing deal ends soon, remortgaging may still win on total cost. The calculators below make this comparison explicit for specific figures.
A Worked Cost Example
Abstract comparisons are hard to evaluate. The following example shows how the numbers play out in a realistic scenario.
Suppose a homeowner wants to borrow £40,000 for a home renovation. They have a fixed-rate mortgage at 2.1% with two years remaining on the fixed period, an outstanding balance of £180,000 on a property worth £380,000, and an ERC of £3,600 (2% of the balance). The best available remortgage rate for their profile is 5.2%. A secured loan is available at 9.0%.
| Cost item | Secured loan route | Remortgage route |
|---|---|---|
| Rate on the £40,000 borrowed | 9.0% | 5.2% |
| Term on the £40,000 borrowed | 10 years | 15 years |
| Monthly cost of the £40,000 borrowing | £507 | £321 |
| Total interest on the £40,000 | £20,804 | £17,690 |
| Early repayment charge | £0 | £3,600 |
| Total cost of the additional borrowing | £20,804 | £21,290 |
Show the working
Secured loan: £40,000 at 9.0% over 10 years
Remortgage: £40,000 at 5.2% over 15 years
Break-even ERC
All figures use the standard amortising formula: M = P × r(1+r)ⁿ ÷ ((1+r)ⁿ − 1). Rates are treated as nominal annual rates with monthly compounding and no fees; a lender's quoted APR will differ slightly. Monthly payments shown to two decimal places; totals rounded to the nearest pound. The comparison covers only the cost of the additional £40,000 borrowing under each route, not the existing mortgage balance. Rates are illustrative, not current market quotes.
In this scenario the secured loan is approximately £486 cheaper overall. The lower remortgage rate on the extra £40,000 is more than offset by the ERC. This illustrates the key insight: the ERC does not need to be enormous to make a secured loan competitive on total cost, particularly when the secured loan has a shorter term (10 years vs 15 in this example).
If the ERC were £5,000 instead of £3,600, the secured loan would be approximately £1,886 cheaper overall. If the ERC were £0 (mortgage at end of its fixed term), the remortgage would be approximately £3,114 cheaper over the same periods. The break-even ERC in this scenario, the exact charge at which the two options cost the same, is approximately £3,114. Any ERC above that figure makes the secured loan the more cost-effective route. Use the calculator below to run the same comparison with your own figures.
Cost Comparison Calculator
Adjust the inputs to reflect your situation. This calculator compares the total cost of each route for the amount you want to borrow, and shows the break-even ERC. It does not model your full mortgage, only the cost of the additional borrowing under each option; the full comparator further down the page does that. Figures are illustrative.
Interactive tool
Secured Loan vs Remortgage: Cost Comparison Calculator
Set the amount, the rate and term for each route, and any early repayment charge. See the total cost of the new borrowing under each route and the break-even ERC at which they cost the same.
Your data stays private — nothing you enter is stored, transmitted, or accessible to anyone. All calculations run entirely in your browser.
Amount and secured loan details
Remortgage details
Remortgage route
Secured loan route
Illustrative only. Compares the cost of the additional borrowing under each route, not your total mortgage. Rates are treated as nominal annual rates with no fees. Actual costs depend on rates and fees offered to you. Obtain quotes from lenders and seek independent advice before deciding.
Model Your Full Mortgage Position
The calculator above answers one question well: is the ERC big enough to make the secured loan cheaper on the new money? It deliberately leaves the existing mortgage out. That is fine when your existing deal is at or near today's rates, but it understates the case for a secured loan when your existing rate is low, and it hides the cost of stretching existing debt over a new, longer term.
Run the worked example through the full picture and the gap changes dramatically. Remortgaging the whole £220,000 at 5.2% over 15 years costs roughly £317,300 in total repayments before the ERC. Keeping the £180,000 at 2.1% over its remaining 20 years and adding £40,000 at 9% over 10 years costs roughly £281,400. Once the £3,600 ERC is added to the remortgage, the secured loan route is around £39,500 cheaper over the full term, against £486 when only the new money is compared. Almost all of that difference is the cost of giving up the 2.1% rate on £180,000 of existing debt.
The comparator opens on the worked example's figures with a 20-year remaining mortgage term assumed. Replace them with your own outstanding balance, current rate and remaining term, then adjust the rate and term sliders for each route to reflect what you might realistically be offered.
Interactive tool
Secured Loan vs Remortgage: Full Mortgage Comparator
Set your existing mortgage details and how much you want to borrow. The tool models both routes side by side, including what happens to your existing balance, and shows monthly payments, total cost, the interest on the new money only, and the break-even ERC.
Your data stays private — nothing you enter is stored, transmitted, or accessible to anyone. All calculations run entirely in your browser.
Your existing mortgage
How much do you want to borrow?
Adjust each route to compare
All figures are illustrative only and are not a quote, offer, or financial advice. Calculations use the standard amortising formula (reducing balance, monthly compounding) based solely on the rate and term you enter, with rates treated as nominal annual rates. They do not include arrangement fees, valuation fees, legal costs, or broker fees, which can be significant and will affect which route is cheaper in practice. The early repayment charge field, if used, adds a one-off cost to Route A's total but is not included in the monthly payment calculation. The rate you are offered on either product will depend on your credit history, income, equity, and the lender's assessment of your circumstances. Taking a secured loan or remortgage is normally an advised process in the UK; a qualified broker will assess your full situation. Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on a mortgage or other debt secured on it.
Risks of Each Option
Both routes involve securing debt against a property, which means the fundamental risk is the same: the property may be repossessed if repayments are not maintained. This is a legal right held by any lender with a registered charge. The risk is real rather than theoretical and applies regardless of how comfortably affordable the repayments seem at the point of taking the loan. Circumstances change (income falls, interest rates rise, unexpected costs emerge) and a sensible affordability assessment needs to account for plausible adverse scenarios, not just the present situation.
The secured loan route carries a specific additional dimension of risk: two lenders each hold a charge on the property. In a default scenario, both can potentially pursue enforcement. The second charge lender, who ranks behind the first in priority, may face a shortfall if the property sale proceeds do not fully cover both debts. This does not mean the risk to the borrower is doubled (both lenders are FCA-regulated and must follow the same pre-enforcement requirements) but it does mean more parties are involved if things go wrong. For the remortgage route, the risk is concentrated in one lender and one repayment, which is simpler to manage, but the higher combined mortgage balance means more is at stake if the property declines in value. The risks of secured loans guide and the what happens if you cannot repay guide cover the consequences of default in detail.
Using a Broker
The comparison between a secured loan and a remortgage involves accessing two distinct markets with different lender panels. Mortgage brokers typically specialise in first charge products; secured loan brokers specialise in second charge products. Some whole-of-market brokers cover both, which is the most useful starting point for this comparison. A broker who can source quotes from both markets simultaneously can produce a genuine like-for-like comparison with live rate quotes and fee schedules, rather than the illustrative figures a calculator can provide.
FCA rules require brokers to disclose how they are remunerated and to act in the customer's best interest. Both mortgage brokers and secured loan brokers must be FCA-authorised, which can be verified on the Financial Services Register. A good broker will also establish whether consent is needed from the existing mortgage lender before a second charge can be registered: many mortgage terms require it, and confirming the position early avoids delays later in the process. The document checklist covers what to have ready before either application.
Tools to help you assess your position
Calculator
Directly relevant to the "how a secured loan works to raise capital" section: shows how much equity is available in the property and what combined LTV a proposed secured loan would represent. The combined LTV position determines both the maximum available loan amount and the rate band that applies, both of which affect whether the secured loan or remortgage route is more cost-effective.
Tool
Secured loan eligibility checker
Provides a soft-search eligibility assessment across income, credit profile, and LTV simultaneously, without leaving a mark on the credit file. Directly relevant to this comparison: obtaining an indicative secured loan rate before approaching a mortgage broker allows a genuine total cost comparison to be made before any formal applications are submitted.
Not sure what to look at next?
All of our secured loan guides and tools in one placeFrequently Asked Questions
Can I take a secured loan if my mortgage has no ERC but I want to protect my rate?
Yes. Rate protection is one of the main reasons to choose a secured loan even when no ERC applies. If you fixed at a low rate a few years ago and still have time left on that deal, remortgaging today would replace it on your entire balance with a current market rate that is likely to be several percentage points higher. The secured loan sits alongside the existing mortgage and leaves the low rate completely intact. The cost of protecting that rate is the higher second charge rate on the new borrowing, but for many borrowers the saving on the existing balance makes this worthwhile even before ERC considerations.
The break-even question in this situation is different from the ERC question. Instead of comparing ERC vs rate differential, you are comparing the higher rate on the new borrowing against the cost of losing the favourable rate on the existing balance for the remaining fixed period. The more you owe on the existing mortgage, the more valuable rate protection becomes, even at a higher second charge rate. The full mortgage comparator on this page puts a figure on that trade-off.
Can I remortgage if my circumstances have changed?
A remortgage involves a full reassessment of your mortgage application, including income, employment, and credit history, by the new lender. If your circumstances have changed since you took out your original mortgage - for example, if you have become self-employed, your income has reduced, or you have had some credit issues - you may find that you no longer qualify for the same level of mortgage borrowing at a competitive rate.
In those situations, a secured loan may be available where a remortgage is not, because the secured loan assessment takes a different approach to affordability and credit. The eligibility checker is a useful way to understand how your current circumstances are likely to be assessed before approaching a lender.
Does taking out a secured loan affect my existing mortgage?
Taking a secured loan does not directly affect your existing mortgage rate, term, or monthly payment. Your existing mortgage continues exactly as it was. However, your existing mortgage lender is notified when a second charge is registered against the property, and many mortgage terms require you to obtain the lender's consent before taking additional secured borrowing. In practice, mainstream lenders usually grant this consent, but it is a step in the process and your broker will handle it as part of the application.
There is also a longer-term effect to plan for. When your fixed-rate deal ends and you go to remortgage, the secured loan will be visible on your credit file as a running commitment. Mortgage lenders assess total debt service (all monthly repayments as a proportion of income) when deciding whether to approve a new deal, so a secured loan may reduce the maximum mortgage available at renewal or, in some cases, affect acceptance. It is not an automatic barrier, particularly if affordability is strong and the loan has been managed cleanly, but it is worth factoring in at the outset. When you do remortgage to a new lender, that lender will need to take account of the existing second charge; in most cases the second charge lender simply remains in place, but it adds a step to the legal process.
Which option is faster if I need the money quickly?
A secured loan is typically faster. The second charge mortgage process usually takes four to eight weeks from application to funds, and a well-prepared application with all documentation ready can complete at the lower end of that range. A remortgage involving a new lender usually takes two to four weeks longer, because the existing mortgage has to be discharged and a new one drawn, with both lenders' legal teams involved. A further advance from your existing lender can be quicker (sometimes two to three weeks), but the rate is not always competitive against the full market. The how long a secured loan takes guide explains the process stages in detail.
If speed is a genuine priority, the secured loan is usually the better route regardless of the cost comparison. The certainty of a shorter, more predictable timeline is itself valuable when borrowing for a specific purpose with a deadline: a planned renovation, a purchase opportunity, or a time-sensitive consolidation.
What happens to the secured loan when I sell the property?
When a property is sold, all charges registered against it must be discharged from the sale proceeds before the balance is passed to the seller. The first charge mortgage is repaid first, then the second charge secured loan. If the sale price is sufficient to cover both, the process is straightforward and the seller receives the remaining equity. If the property has fallen in value and the combined debt exceeds the sale price, a shortfall arises and the second charge lender may not be fully repaid. In that case, the lender would pursue the borrower for the outstanding amount, typically through the courts.
This scenario (negative equity with a second charge) is uncommon in a rising or stable market but becomes a realistic risk in a falling market, particularly if the property was bought or remortgaged at the peak of a cycle. Both lenders would typically need to agree before a sale could proceed where proceeds are insufficient, which can complicate and delay the sale process. Maintaining a reasonable equity buffer above the combined debt position reduces this risk.
What do the calculators leave out?
Both calculators model capital and interest only, using the rates and terms you enter, with an optional early repayment charge added to the remortgage route. They do not include arrangement fees, valuation fees, legal costs, or broker fees, any of which can be significant on either route and can change which one is cheaper. They also treat rates as fixed for the whole term; in practice a remortgage will revert or be refinanced at the end of its fixed period, and a variable-rate secured loan can move. Our guide to secured loan fees covers what to add back in, and the APR guide explains how to compare offers once fees are included.
Squaring Up
The choice between a secured loan and a remortgage comes down to one central question: does breaking your existing mortgage deal cost more than the rate premium on a second charge loan? That question cannot be answered in the abstract: it depends on the ERC amount, the rate you would give up on the existing balance, the rate differential between first and second charge products in the current market, the amount being borrowed, and the terms of each loan. The quick calculator isolates the break-even ERC on the new money; the full comparator shows what each route does to your whole mortgage position. For a genuine market comparison with live rate quotes, a broker with access to both mortgage and secured loan markets is the most practical next step.
Both routes carry real repossession risk and should only be taken on with a clear affordability assessment that holds up under adverse scenarios. Neither is a low-stakes decision: both increase the total debt secured against the property and both require sustained repayment discipline to avoid the consequences of default.
Continue your research
Guides, calculators, and comparators covering every aspect of secured lending Explore guides and toolsUpdate log: September 2026
What changed in this update
This guide now brings together our two secured loan vs remortgage resources in one place. The full mortgage comparator, which models your existing balance, rate and remaining term under each route alongside the new borrowing, has been added below the worked example, with a new section explaining what it shows that the quick cost comparison does not. Both tools now open on the same illustrative figures as the worked example, share the same colour coding, and show a break-even ERC. The quick calculator gains a like-for-like note when the two terms differ, a higher ERC ceiling, and improved screen reader support.
The decision framework has a sixth trigger covering changed circumstances, and the FAQs now cover remortgaging after your circumstances change, how a second charge interacts with your existing mortgage, and what the calculators leave out. Timelines have been aligned with our guide to how long a secured loan takes, the further advance option is described alongside remortgaging, and rate references have been refreshed for the current market. Cross-links to the remortgage timing calculator, the second charge vs further advance comparator, the secured loan calculator and the document checklist have been added.
July 2026
The full comparator gained an optional early repayment charge field, a "monthly after loan repaid" figure for the secured loan route, standardised rate labels, a total cost comparison in place of a total interest comparison, and accessibility improvements to WCAG 2.1 AA including screen reader support for dynamic results and enhanced keyboard navigation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Calculator figures are illustrative and based on the inputs entered; they do not represent a quote from any lender and do not include arrangement, valuation, legal or broker fees. Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on a mortgage or other debt secured on it. Always obtain independent financial advice before making significant borrowing decisions.
Spread the Word


